
“During the summer of 1999, the town of Erie, Pennsylvania experienced an unusually high number of deaths.” So begins Alison-Eve Hammersley’s found footage flick, set in the exact year which first saw unsuspecting audiences questioning the lines between fiction and reality courtesy of The Blair Witch Project. Erie does feature a woodland setting, mysterious events and more than enough scratchy, shaky camcorder action to satiate fans of this now crowded corner of horror, but the nods to Myrick and Sanchez’s groundbreaking work are more down to the shadow it has cast over everything of a vaguely similar ilk that’s followed since.
Stella Scott (Carly Stewart) is an aspiring journalist who has skin in the game when it comes to the weirdness surrounding the place in which she grew up, as the death of her sister Iris in the very same area doesn’t appear to be the suicide it has been ruled. She teams up with her somewhat sceptical brother Oscar (Grant Carter) in an effort to piece together all of the disparate information about the various folks who have been found deceased. Their early investigations lead them to strange local Red (Ryan W. Garcia) whose now ex-partner Brenda has gone the same way as Iris.
In terms of the subgenre, Erie sticks to the template of those early movies in its plotting, with mystery and misdirection for most of the opening hour and then chaos in the final act. There’s a leisurely introduction to the sister-brother team and more than enough detail as to the background of the strange occurrences, given even more space for consideration when Red comes onto the scene with his obsessive nature and odd behaviour.
When the movie focuses on this trio, there’s a pleasing, added dimension of disrupting the sibling squabbling via the introduction of a barely welcome outsider who not only believes that the deaths are murders, but may also be the murderer himself. This ramps up both the tension and the dark humour, with Garcia leaning into the unpredictability of such a character and looming large over a sizeable chunk of the proceedings, even when Stella and Oscar’s plan is to ditch the guy.
So far, so found footagey. However, there’s an unexpected creative choice which ushers in a different feel to those closing twenty minutes and will almost certainly prove divisive. It may drive some to frustration, even a fit of pique, in the way that it casts aside a specific, important tenet of the found footage movie. Obviously I’m not going to give it away here, but it’s a watershed moment which risks taking viewers out of the movie completely and, although I took a moment and then rolled with the adjustment, I get why some viewers might not stick with it.
Without trying to give away too many spoilers, the late shift does give an alternative perspective to the growing hopelessness of the situation, while still sticking to that feeling of there being no way out of a forest where every turn seems to lead to somewhere even less familiar. Stewart gets to show some impressive acting chops here as the physical and mental agony of her situation begins to take its toll, leading to a neat, if rather cruel, last minute rug pull.
Erie may be trying to have its cake and eat it too by harking back to those seminal days of the found footage movie while trying a couple of audacious tricks of its own, but there’s no denying that the grainy video visuals and boxy screen ratio are spot on, as are the sporadic of intrusions of a filmed home life at various points of the tape. Stewart and Carter are engaging as the bickering protagonists who slowly reveal their weaknesses as the gravity of their plight comes into frightening focus. As with the protagonists of The Blair Witch Project, the frequent arguing and the naivety of their mission tempts the viewer into having less sympathy for them but ultimately, when the real danger hits, there’s an overwhelming feeling that in no way do they deserve to die.
Whereas I don’t feel Erie worked entirely for me, I found it an interesting and well-written take on familiar tropes and there’s a confidence about the filmmaking which carries it through. Stewart and Carter ground the work, Garcia throws the amusing and unnerving curveballs and those last few minutes are, in my book, worth turning a blind eye to the conventions of the expected template. Purists, however, may not agree.
Erie (2026) received its UK premiere at this year’s Soho Horror Film Festival. For more details, click here.